Learn from the mistakes of others

ZDNet UK report:

ID card compromise reached in Parliament

Sylvia Carr
silicon.com
March 30, 2006, 17:30 BST

The Commons and the Lords have both passed an amended form of the government's ID cards bill

Both houses of Parliament have agreed to a compromise proposal that will see ID cards become mandatory for passport holders by 2010.

Previously the ID cards bill, which the House of Lords has rejected five times over the past few weeks, required anyone renewing a passport to also receive an ID card by 2008.

The amendments mean that until 2010 those renewing passports will be able to opt out of receiving an ID card but will still have their biometric and other personal details entered into the National Identity Register — the database which ID card opponents have objected to along with the issuing of the actual cards.

In a vote yesterday, the Lords approved the amended proposal by 287 to 60 while MPs passed it 301 to 84.

Charles Clarke, the home secretary, said pricing for the ID cards will be determined once the bill becomes law.

Home Office minister Andy Burnham said he was "delighted" to back the amended proposal and added it "preserves the integrity" of the National Identity Register while "meeting the concerns" of those who opposed mandatory ID cards.

silicon.com had this to say:

New ID cards agency set up after Queen approves bill
Critics of the scheme vow to fight on...

By Andy McCue

Friday 31 March 2006

The government has wasted no time in starting work on the controversial ID card scheme after the bill became law this week, and has set up a new agency that will be tasked with introducing ID cards.

The ID cards bill is now on the statute book after receiving Royal Assent from the Queen yesterday. The new Identity and Passport Service (IPS), which will be in charge of managing the ID cards scheme, will become operational from 1 April 2006.

The bill finally got approval following a deal between MPs and peers in the House of Lords earlier this week which allows people to opt out of receiving an ID card when renewing their passport until 2010.

But the compromise means that those who choose to opt out will still have to pay for the ID card - and have their fingerprints, iris scans and personal details taken and stored on the national identity register (NIR) when they get a new passport.

Home Secretary Charles Clarke has already announced that the Labour government will make the scheme compulsory if it wins the next general election and a new agency to issue passports and ID cards has already been set up.

The position of CEO of the new IPS agency, which will incorporate the existing UK Passport Service, has yet to be advertised but the Home Office said it expects the role to be filled later in the year.

The IPS will be responsible for issuing ID cards and providing the means of verifying the identity of individuals for accredited organisations, setting up the NIR and promoting the use of ID cards in the public and private sectors.

Clarke said in a statement: "Building on the experience and proven excellence of the Passport Service, the IPS will ensure the UK is at the forefront of the worldwide drive to increase document security, safeguard borders and protect identities for use by those who are entitled to them."

But critics of the ID card scheme have vowed to fight on. Phil Booth, national co-ordinator for the No2ID campaign group, said the problem has always been the national identity database rather than the card.

He said: "Millions are already vehemently opposed. The Home Office will have to round them up and force them to be fingerprinted which will bring home to the public the true nature of the scheme. This is a self-destructive policy to dwarf the Poll Tax."

guess it won't be long before we're playing good little allies and following suit ...